Top 6 Crocs Butter Alternatives: Cheaper Ways To Shiny Crocs

Written By Saraf

If you are anything like me, you like to keep your footwear shiny and spotless at all times. This doesn’t just apply to formal shoes, but regular ones as well – such as our very beloved Crocs.

Crocs are super comfortable and wearable, but keeping their shine alive is very important to maintain a neat finish.

You can get Crocs butter on their website and store to keep your Crocs polished to perfection.

But getting your hands on Crocs butter is not always possible, or it may seem expensive and replaceable to some of you.

So, is it replaceable? Are there other products that you can use to keep your Crocs glossy as new?

If you said yes, then you are correct because there are much cheaper and more convenient alternatives to Crocs butter and I will be telling you all the details about them right here, my friend.

So, without further ado, let’s dive into it.crocs-butter-alternatives

Follow our guide on how to Spot Fake Vs. Real Crocs

Top 6 Crocs Butter Alternatives You Must Try

Keeping your shoes neat and clean says a lot about a person.

You will notice that whenever you see a person with dirty and untidy shoes, your first impression of that person will not be up to the mark.

So, to keep up your appearances and also feel neat, clean, and proper yourself, you need to keep your shoes clean and shiny – whether it’s formal shoes, a pair of sneakers, or your favorite Crocs.

Now, you can use Crocs butter to bring back the shine to your crocs after washing and drying them but not everyone is a big fan of Crocs butter.

Check out our epic guide on how to Make Crocs Shiny Again

Many people think that Crocs butter is not worth the price, many reviews on amazon say that it doesn’t work as well, or works like any other shoe butter.

Hence, people like you and me often want alternatives to Crocs butter.

Also, getting your hands on crocs butter is not always easy, they may be out of stock, or you may not have access to the crocs stores from where you live.

So, what should you do in such cases?

Below, I have mentioned the best alternative to crocs butter that you can use according to your convenience.

In a hurry? Check out to know about Crocs Vs. Skechers: Which One Is The Better Option?

Armor Oil

One of the best, if not the best, alternatives to crocs butter is Armor oil.

In fact, even the employees at crocs themselves have recommended the use of Armor oil to rejuvenate the shine of your old crocs and make them look shiny as new.armor-oil

What is armor oil?

It is a unique mixture of eucalyptus, lemon, rosemary, cinnamon, and clove. This oil has antimicrobial properties and is usually used as a hand cleaner or household surface cleaner.

You can use this armor oil to bring back the shine and make your crocs look sleek again.

It works similarly to crocs butter.

Follow our guide to know Are Crocs Unisex

It doesn’t only bring back the shine, it also acts as a protectant and prevents your crocs from cracking.

Make sure you fully wash, clean, and dry your crocs before putting this oil on the surface.

Once they are dry, all you have to do is apply a generous amount of armor oil over and around your crocs. After that, leave them to air dry for about five to ten minutes.

After application, your crocs will look glossy and brand new!

Pros
  • »Effective
  • »Easy to use
  • »Low cost
  • »Pleasant scent
Cons
  • »Not easy to find at regular stores

Follow our epic guide to know about Crocs LiteRide Vs Classic Crocs: Comparison Guide

Shoe Cream

Even though crocs butter may sound fancy and all, it’s purpose is to make your used crocs polished and shiny – which is something that can also be achieved using shoe cream.

You read that right, you can simply use your regular shoe cream or get new ones from Target to polish your crocs after washing and drying them.

You will be surprised to see how well they work.

Moreover, they are much cheaper than Crocs butter and can be found at any convenience store close to your house.

Buying shoe creams won’t be a loss because they are a multipurpose alternative to your crocs butter because they can be used on your leather shoes and bags as well.shoe-cream

In a hurry? Check out to know about Crocs Classic Vs. Crocs All Terrain: Ultimate Comparison Guide

So, shoe cream is the perfect affordable and convenient alternative that does a great job.

The steps are pretty simple – once your crocs are washed, clean and dry, apply the shoe cream all over the exterior of your crocs using a cotton cloth.

The plus point here is that the shoe cream will also restore the color of your crocs and act as a conditioning and protective layer.

Pros
  • »Effective
  • »Easy to use
  • »Low cost
  • »Restores color
Cons
  • »Have to be careful about the color (do not use dark colored shoe cream on light color crocs)

Also, check out our separate post on Oofos Vs Crocs: An Epic Comparison Guide

Magic Eraser

Crazy as it may sound, you can use a magic eraser on your crocs as an alternative to crocs butter.

Magic eraser is a type of eraser with different chemicals incorporated with the rubber so that it can be used to get rid of stubborn stains from different kinds of surfaces.

Just like crocs butter, magic eraser can also make your crocs shiny and new-looking.

Moreover, the magic eraser will also get rid of all kinds of stubborn stains from your crocs. They are also quite inexpensive.magic-eraser

Follow our guide to know Can You Wear Crocs On A Treadmill

So, instead of just making your crocs look shiny, it is also removing unwanted stains from the crocs, that’s two in one!

The steps to use the magic eraser on your crocs is fairly simple. First, you have to wash, clean, and dry your crocs.

Once that’s done, scrub all over your crocs using the magic eraser for about three to four minutes.

After you’re done, you will see that your crocs look shiny, neat, and fantastic!

Pros
  • »Effective
  • »Low cost
Cons
  • »Can be tiring to use
  • »Not easy to find at regular stores

In a hurry? Check out my new post: Do Crocs Make Your Feet Stink

Coconut Oil

I have told you about armor oil, but when it comes to rejuvenating and glossing out your crocs, coconut oil does a great job as well.

Like most people, if you have coconut oil somewhere in the house, you can simply use that on your crocs instead of buying crocs butter, as it acts as a great replacement.

First and foremost, thoroughly clean and dry your crocs.

Once it’s done, take a piece of cotton cloth, get a good amount of coconut oil onto it and dab it all over your crocs. They will start to shine like they’re new!coconut-oil

Check out my separate post to know Are Men’s Crocs Wider Than Women’s

The only drawback is that coconut oil has a distant smell and it can be unpleasant to some people. But if you don’t mind the smell of coconut oil, then this is a great alternative to crocs butter for you.

Pros
  • »Effective
  • »Easy to use
Cons
  • »Unpleasant odor
  • »Can be expensive

Follow our guide on Nothinz Vs Crocs: Which One Should You Get

Petroleum Jelly

Believe it or not, you can also use petroleum jelly to condition and rejuvenate your crocs.

This is super convenient because almost everyone has petroleum jelly at their place, I’m sure you do too and it’s uses are not limited to just applying on the skin!

Just like crocs butter, you can also use petroleum jelly to make your crocs shine.

The process is also exactly the same.petroleum-jelly

Also, follow our guide to know Do Crocs Melt

Wash, clean, and dry your crocs, once it’s done apply the petroleum jelly all over your crocs, rubbing it in using a piece of cloth. Thoroughly rub it in and you will see that the results are fantastic.

Pros
  • »Effective
  • »Easy to use
  • »Low cost
  • »Available at home (in most cases)
Cons
  • »Application can get messy

But before that, check out Why Do Your Crocs Smell So Bad

Body Oil Or Lotion

Another convenient alternative to crocs butter is body lotion or body oil. Whichever you have at home, you can use that on your crocs to make them look shiny and new.

And don’t worry, the body lotion/oil won’t damage your crocs in any way. It does not have any negative effect on the material used to manufacture Crocs, Croslite.

One great thing about using body lotion is that you can get great results with any kind of body lotion or oil that you have at home.

However, one thing you must be careful about when using body lotion on your crocs is that it can get greasy if you use too much of it.

Check out our separate guide to know Crocs Vs Yeezy Slidesbody-lotion

So, I would suggest using a dime-sized amount and slowly building up if needed.

The steps for the application are the same and simple – wash, clean and dry your crocs.

Once this is done, apply small amounts of the lotion/oil over your crocs in circular motions, rubbing it in well using a piece of cotton cloth.

Pros
  • »Effective
  • »Easy to use
  • »Low cost
  • »Available at home
Cons
  • »Can get greasy if too much applied

Also, follow our epic guide to know Can You Put Crocs In The Washing Machine

Is It Necessary To Use Crocs Butter?

One thing for sure is that you should practice polishing your crocs after washing and drying them. This will make them shine and prevent your crocs from cracking or getting damaged, extending their lifespan.

Crocs butter has been specially manufactured by the crocs company to polish crocs.

However, they are not the only product that can be used to polish and shine your crocs.

In fact, there are much better alternatives that you can use to shine, maintain, and protect your crocs.

So, it is not mandatory that you use only crocs butter, but instead, I highly recommend you use the alternatives mentioned above at your convenience.

In a hurry? Check out my new post: Do Crocs Come In Half Sizes

Related Questions

Can Crocs Be Washed In The Washing Machine?

Crocs are made of an excellent material called Croslite. This enables them to be washed in the washing machine without any problem.

To wash them thoroughly, all you need to do is add some detergent and wash them in a hand wash setting.

However, I must warn you that you cannot dry them using the dryer on the washing machine, as such a high temperature can cause the Croslite to melt.

Instead, you should air dry them.

What Is Crocs Butter Made Of?

Crocs butter is a polishing formula, manufactured and sold by the crocs company.

It is made using a mixture of different plant-based oils, salt, citric acid, pea protein, sunflower lecithin, vitamin A, natural flavors, Beta carotene, and water.

This shine restoring solution comes in a box with a sponge applicator, with is quite handy and not messy.

Final Verdict

While crocs butter is great for making your used crocs look shiny and new, the same task and result can be achieved using many other kinds of alternatives.

I have mentioned the best, most convenient, and most effective alternatives in this article, and I think you should try them out to check which one is the best option for you.

So, try them out and let me know which one works the best for you, in the comments below.

And don’t forget to let me know what topic you want me to cover next.

About The Author
Saraf is a pharmacist with a passion for footwear and fashion. Writing is her favorite hobby besides reading. She loves helping people in all sorts of ways, that’s when she decided why not help people in this regard as well? So now, she’s here with all her expertise.

Leave a Comment